New revenue recognition standard means big changes for software companies 3222016 the financial accounting standards boards fasb new principlesbased rules on revenue recognition will significantly change the way your software company determines when and how to recognize revenue. Sop 972, software revenue recognition, provides detailed guidance on accounting for revenue associated with software and software related arrangements. A contract that is considered a series of distinct goods or services under asc 606 would be considered a multiple element arrangement under asc 605. Under the prior revenue standard, software contracts that meet these. The guidance on accounting for arrangements with multiple deliverables is primarily codified in asc 60525, revenue recognition multipleelement arrangements. Multiple element arrangement how is multiple element. For example, if a contract promises to customize an offtheshelf software system to. Revenue recognitionmultiple elements arrangements, and the. This video shows how to recognize revenue for bundled services in a multielement arrangement.
What it does say in ias 18, revenue, indicates a fair value approach to revenue recognition, which is not what fasb is dictating. Now, going back to the specific question of whether or not this companys multiple element arrangements have been handled correctly, i would say that it would be very unusual for a multiple element arrangement to have a delivered item with standalone value and an undelivered element. This guidance is codified in asc 985605, software revenue recognition. According to the sop, there are different accounting rules applicable when elements are considered a software element or a service element. Multiple deliverable arrangements february 06, 2015 revenue recognition is an increasingly important topic for private companies operating in the technology and. The customer has the contractual right to take possession of the software at any time during the hosting period without significant penalty. Subtopic 60525, revenue recognition multipleelement arrangements, of the financial accounting standards boards accounting standards codification asc provides the guidance that should be followed in accounting for this and many other revenue arrangements with multiple deliverables. The attached publication, multipleelement arrangementsa roadmap to applying the revenue recognition.
Under asc 605, an entity evaluates the contract and identifies separate units of accounting. As technology becomes further entrenched in consumer and enterprise products, companies outside of the traditional software. Guidance on applying for asc 60525, revenue recognition multipleelement arrangements, including examples illustrating various concepts. Revenue recognition on software arrangements appendix c of sop 972 110 glossary from sop 972 1 appendix a multipleelement arrangements. The new revenue recognition guidance has been incorporated in asc 60525, revenue recognitionmultiple element arrangements, and asc 985, software. Sop 972 provides the necessary guidance when dealing with multiple element arrangements. Revenue recognition under multielement arrangements.
Revenue recognition for technology companies for multiple. Accounting for bundled services multielement arrangements for. It applies to both public companies according to sab 104 and private enterprises. Revenue recognition for technology companies for multipleelement arrangements under ifrs 15. The legacy guidance allowed software entities to account for a delivered item for example, the software license delivered upfront as a separate element only if the entity had vendorspecific objective evidence of fair. The arrangement calls for the vendor to perform the installation.
The unit of account for revenue recognition under the new standard is a performance obligation a good or service. Befitting its principles basis, ifrs says little about multipleelement arrangements. Revenue recognition on software arrangements appendix c of sop 972. Multiple element arrangements additional software deliverables and rights to exchange or. Specifically, this subtopic addresses how to separate deliverables and how to measure and allocate. Multi element arrangements may include additional software products, rights to purchase additional software products at a significant incremental discount, specified upgrades or. Differences between gaap and ifrs on revenue recognition. The attached publication, multipleelement arrangementsa roadmap to applying the revenue recognition guidance in asu 2009, which is the latest addition to deloittes roadmap series, summarizes the changes made by asu 2009 and provides interpretive guidance on applying its provisions. A comprehensive guide revenue recognition multiple. Revenue recognition impact on biotech industry softrax. New revenue recognition standard means big changes for. This approach is similar to the multiple element arrangement rules in the current revenue recognition standards. Overview of effects of vsoe of fair value on revenue recognition and measurement requirements 115.
Multipleelement arrangements a roadmap to applying the. A comprehensive guide revenue recognition multiple element. Subtopic 60525, revenue recognition multipleelement arrangements, of the financial accounting standards board s accounting standards codification asc provides the guidance that should be followed in accounting for this and many other revenue arrangements. Revenue recognition multipleelement arrangements asc 60525 provides guidance on the separability of deliverables included in an arrangement into different units of accounting and the. Revenue recognition within the software industry has historically been highly complex with much industryspecific guidance. The revenue associated with a given element is recognized after the firm. Fasb asu 2009, multipledeliverable revenue arrangements, changes the accounting for revenue recognition arrangements with multiple deliverables. Under the prior revenue standard, software contracts that meet these criteria were accounted for under asc topic 985605, revenue recognitionsoftware. Topic provides the staffs views regarding the general revenue recognition guidance codified in asc topic 605. Sop 972, software revenue recognition, provides guidance on when revenue should be recognized and in what amounts for licensing, selling, leasing or otherwise marketing computer software. Further, in accordance with asc 60525 revenue recognition, multiple element arrangements. Jun 05, 2007 if a multiple element software arrangement includes explicit or implicit rights to pcs, pcs is a separate element of the arrangement. Revenue recognition software sop 972 wittsiepe consulting. Sop 972 provides the necessary guidance when dealing with multipleelement arrangements.
Assume the equipment and the installation are separate units of accounting under fasb asc subtopic 60525, revenue recognition multiple element arrangements. Asc topic 606 provides a single set of revenue recognition principles governing all contracts with customers and supersedes the revenue recognition framework in asc topic 605, which eliminates the need for topic. Revenue recognition topic 605 affects accounting and reporting for all vendors that enter into multiple deliverable arrangements with their customers. Asc 98560555121 states that for a software element in a hosting arrangement to be subject to the software revenue recognition guidance in asc 985605, the following criteria must be satisfied. Kpmgs revenue recognition survey of technology companies. Fasb accounting standards update asu 2009, multiple deliverable revenue arrangements, significantly changes the accounting for revenue recognition arrangements with multiple deliverables.
Subtopic 60525, revenue recognition multipleelement arrangements. This type of transaction frequently occurs for technology firms that sell a variety of. For example, similar to multiple element arrangement guidelines in. For a manufactured product, should revenue be recognized when the item rolls off of the assembly line. Revenue recognition changes require businesses to disclose more about. The sop provides instruction on recognition for licensing, selling, leasing or otherwise marketing software. Multiple elements accounted for as a single element.
Gaap where there are multiple deliverables in revenue arrangements, the arrangements are divided into separate unit of accounting provided deliverables meet all of the specified criteria defined under gaap. The guidance on accounting for arrangements with multiple deliverables is primarily codified in asc 60525. The primary authority for software revenue recognition is aicpa statement of position sop no. A deep dive into multipleelement revenue recognition. Revenue arrangements with multiple deliverables a member of fasbs emerging issues task force shares insights on new guidance for revenue. Subscribe to weekly revenue recognition update industry. Companies across the globe are intensively rearchitecting their revenue recognition processes and policies as a result of the new asc 606 guidance. In most situations, the new guidance will result in earlier revenue recognition for financial reporting purposes. Multipleelement arrangements a roadmap to applying the revenue recognition guidance in asu 2009 1 summarizes the changes that were made by asu 2009 and 2 provides interpretive. Under current guidance, firm a would allocate a contract including deliverables within and outside the scope of software revenue recognition between software and nonsoftware components using the relative selling price method based on the multiple element arrangement guidance in asc subparagraph 60525153a. Fasb accounting standards update asu 2009, multipledeliverable revenue arrangements, significantly changes the accounting for revenue recognition arrangements with multiple deliverables. New gaap for multiple deliverables journal of accountancy. We hope that financial statement preparers will find this roadmap helpful. In addition, ias 18 provides limited guidance on important topics such as revenue recognition for multipleelement arrangements.
May 07, 2007 multi element arrangement occurs when a vendor agrees to provide more than one product or a combination of products and services to a customer in an arrangement. New revenue recognition rule is tricky for software and. Multielement arrangements multielement arrangement occurs when a vendor agrees to provide more than one product or a combination of products and services to a customer in an arrangement. Revenue recognition for multiple element arrangements. Revenue recognition for multiple element arrangements, also known as bundled sales or contracts, is a hot issue for cfos these days. At the heart of the issue is how you standardize the revenue recognition across multiple. This is similar to identifying performance obligations under asc 606. Multielement arrangements may include additional software products, rights to purchase additional software. Saas revenue recognition concepts guide software as a. Subtopic 605 25, revenue recognitionmultipleelement arrangements, establishes the accounting and reporting guidance for arrangements under which the vendor will perform multiple revenuegenerating. This type of transaction frequently occurs for technology firms that sell a variety of services e. Executive summary statement of position sop 972 provides guidance on applying gaap in recognizing revenue from software and software related transactions.
Revenue arrangements with multiple deliverables bpm accounting. Revenues from contracts with multiple element arrangements are. Technical guide on revenue recognition for software. What it does say in ias 18, revenue, indicates a fair value approach to revenue recognition, which is not what fasb is. Revenue recognition on software arrangements appendix c of sop 972 110 glossary from sop 972 1 appendix a multiple element arrangements. In this example, we implement the product and maintenance as a bundled product and get the same result using a multiple deliverable arrangement. Implementing the new revenue guidance in the technology industry. The fourth step in the revenue recognition process involves allocating the transaction price. It states that you have to allocate the price relatively, splitting the price amongst the various elements based upon vendor specific objective evidence or vsoe of fair value. Software the primary authority for software revenue recognition is aicpa statement of position sop no.
Vsoe of fair value is essentially the price established for each individual element in the bundle. New revenue guidance implementation in the software industry. For a discussion of the key considerations for technology entities that do not currently apply software guidance, refer to our applying ifrs, the new revenue recognition standard technology january 2015 technology. New eitf revenue recognition standards for multiple. Accounting for multipledeliverable revenue arrangements. Jul 03, 20 revenue recognition under multielement arrangements by kevin lalor jul 3, 20 as we mentioned in yesterdays post, software companies tend to bundle together software licenses fees, installation and maintenance services, training, upgrade rights, and professional services into a multielement product offering. Revenue recognition for a contract with multiple deliverables begins with allocating the. Revenue recognition for multipleelement arrangements consisting of software. Additionally, restatements resulting either from the misapplication of revenue recognition principles to a multiple element arrangement or the improper allocation of arrangement consideration to the various elements included in a multiple element arrangement remain common. This publication summarizes the changes made by asu 2009 and provides interpretive guidance on applying its provisions. In many cases, software licensing companies can recognize a significant portion of the arrangement fee as revenue when the software license is delivered to the customer. Jan 17, 2016 this video shows how to recognize revenue for bundled services in a multi element arrangement. Although defined differently, the closest analogy in todays vernacular to a performance obligation would be a deliverable under the multiple element arrangement. Multiple element arrangements the license of intellectual property, including software, often includes other elements as part of the contract.
For more information about these asus, please see kpmgs issues indepth, october 2009, no. Revenue recognition for software companies softrax. When accounting for multiple element arrangements, gaap indicates that sellers can separately record revenue for part of an arrangement even if the part does not have value to the customer on a stand. Technology spotlight recognizing revenue from saas arrangements. The conditions for revenue recognition are a an exchange transaction, and b the earnings process being complete. Asc 606 does not address updating estimated standalone selling prices. Revenue recognition multipleelement arrangements deloitte us.
Revenue recognition multiple element arrangements revenue recognition asc 60525 was updated by asu 2009 to reflect the contents of eitf 081 eitf issue no. The impact of the new revenue recognition guidance on cloud. Sop 972, software revenue recognition, must be applied to the deliverables within its scope. In a nonpcs arrangement, such as training of customer staff in the use of the software, separate revenue recognition applies only if 1 vsoe see above of fair value exists to allow allocation of revenue to the service elements and the services are not essential to any other element in the arrangement, and 2 the total arrangement fee. Multielement arrangements may include additional software products, rights to purchase additional software products at a significant incremental discount, specified upgrades or enhancements, hardware, pcs or other services. The second fundamental change in standards due to asu 2009 is the approach to the allocation of revenue to the various elements of a multiple element arrangement. Under current guidance, firm a would allocate a contract including deliverables within and outside the scope of software revenue recognition between software and nonsoftware components. An answer is described in sop 972 software revenue recognition rules. Multiple element arrangements containing items that are now excluded from software revenue recognition requirements will now be subject to the separation and allocation guidance in asu 2009. Accounting for multipledeliverable revenue arrangements rsm. The financial accounting standards boards emerging issues task force eitf recently updated guidance regarding recognition of revenue for multiple deliverable arrangements, which is intended to better reflect the underlying economics of such arrangements.
In the process of developing accounting policies for revenue recognition for saas arrangements, vendors may have to look at the guidance in sab topic. Gaap codification of accounting standards guide by. Accounting for bundled services multielement arrangements. Implementing the new revenue guidance in the technology. The fasbs second step on revenue recognition, asc 606, shows. Gaap consolidation identifying a controlling financial interest. Financial reporting developments software revenue recognition 1 1 introduction and scope 1. A contract may contain one or more performance obligations. Companies who sell their software by subscription software. Issues often arise regarding how and whether to separate these deliverables and how to allocate the overall arrangement consideration. The new revenue standard replaces these multiple sets of guidance with a single revenue. Prior to the publication of asc 606 and ifrs 15, revenue recognition standards were not clearly defined. Banking, finance and accounting business accounting accounting software computer services industry standards computer software industry financial software information technology services industry software industry.
Most cloudbased contracts, however, do not meet the above criteria and were accounted for as service contracts that fall under asc topic 60525, revenue recognitionmultiple elements arrangements, and the secs staff accounting bulletin sab 104. Determining how to allocate consideration among elements of an arrangement and when to recognise revenue can be extremely complex and, as a result, industryspecific revenue recognition models were previously developed. These elements to which revenue amounts are assigned by gaap are referred to as separate units of accounting. Revenue recognition under multielement arrangements bi101. Vsoe of fair value is essentially the price established for each individual element. Revenue recognition for software companies softrax industry. Multiple deliverable arrangements february 06, 2015 revenue recognition is an increasingly important topic for private companies operating in the technology and life sciences sector. Revenue recognition normally occurs at the time services are rendered or when goods are sold and delivered. Practical applications of asc 606 for saas companies fei. Nonetheless the boards are working toward common goals, and it is expected that any revision of ias 18 will not be inconsistent with this new u. Revenue recognition topic 605 does not affect arrangements for which industry specific allocation and measurement guidance exists, such as software.
123 144 842 985 11 1311 1315 1269 1332 638 762 1446 233 413 1166 1290 1381 769 1030 594 408 1201 1039 970 1244 769 1326 1207 1099 1146